Why I did it

New Yorker cartoons for the upperclass AND the masses.

Trader Joe’s does it again. Bad pie, TJ.

Posted on December 3, 2008 - Filed Under Donna Does Desserts |


Picture of homemade pie.

You would think that with a title of (take deep breath) Trader Joe’s Chocolate Pumpkin Pecan Praline Tart, how could they miss, right? Nice cheerful orange label with chocolate dots, attractive looking pie. But I won’t make you wait until the end of the review: thumbs down.

(What is the difference between tart and pie? [Pause while I go over to Google.]  Okay, here:

A tart is made with a crust formed in a tart pan or a low, straight-walled pan with a removable bottom. A pie, similar to a tart, is baked in a pie pan that has sloping sides. Both a tart and a pie can have the crust prebaked and filled or baked with fruits, custards or chocolate.

Everything 2 agrees with that. Already, things are not quite right here. This is definitely a pie, not a tart.)

Anyway, it has a sweet crumbly crust. I love soft crusts! But it’s not real chocolate, and it doesn’t taste like chocolate, unless it’s the cheap drugstore kind. The filling has a slightly crunchy filling, of substance, but not hard on your teeth.

Pumpkin is one of my top flavors - I’ve never met a pumpkin product I didn’t like! I can taste the pumpkin, feel the pecans, and very vaguely taste the praline. But it doesn’t add up to much together. And at $6.99 each, it’s too expensive for below average. (I bought this last month, when the economy was slightly better. I wouldn’t even buy it now.)

Trader Joe’s doesn’t have the confidence to post photographs of any of the products it sells. Or the PR know how. So no photo from them. The photo above is from Viking Range, which has lots of other yummy looking recipes.

FULL DISCLOSURE: I hate our local TJ in Silver Lake, and wrote a lyrical poem about it in my other blog: http://donnabarstow.com/park_blog/2008/02/28/i-hate-trader-joes-silver-lake/. But I like the one in Toluca Lake, so perhaps I’m not biased after all.

    Want more like this?
  1. In which I get syndicated.
  2. She needs therapy or good sex, take your pick.
  3. I took my canary for a walk today.

No Comments yet for “Trader Joe’s does it again. Bad pie, TJ.” Leave a comment, s'il vous plait!